Comments on: Kishore - S.D.Burman - A Relationship That Began With ‘Aradhana’ http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html Kishore Kumar Mon, 08 Sep 2008 01:21:09 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.0.4 by: Sushil Parashar http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-7523 Thu, 01 May 2008 07:17:54 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-7523 kishore da always used to say "arrey dil se gao galey se nahin". He was a magician of soz. I could not celebrate my B'day after 13th october 1987. My opinion is do not keep on counting hunderd of thousands of songs of a singer and then strip them out for evaluation that how good or bad that singer is/was. Only ONE song can change some one's life. It is the power of music that will remain everlasting not the individual. Rafi Mukesh or Kishore All are angels of god whose talent has created beautiful environment around us. God bless them all. Kind regards to you all Sushil k parashar kishore da always used to say “arrey dil se gao galey se nahin”. He was a magician of soz. I could not celebrate my B’day after 13th october 1987. My opinion is do not keep on counting hunderd of thousands of songs of a singer and then strip them out for evaluation that how good or bad that singer is/was. Only ONE song can change some one’s life. It is the power of music that will remain everlasting not the individual. Rafi Mukesh or Kishore All are angels of god whose talent has created beautiful environment around us. God bless them all.

Kind regards to you all

Sushil k parashar

]]> by: Gooseberry http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5681 Sun, 16 Dec 2007 05:54:37 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5681 Binu ji - I will disagree with you here. Read some of the comments written by diehard Rafi fans. I think it is in bad taste. Actually there are such fans for both the artistes and it is not fair to say that some writers in this forum are writing anti-Rafi sahab. I love the songs of both these artistes though I am more of a Kishore fan as it is my own liking and passion. Read this post - I think it is in real bad taste. http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/an-endless-feud-between-the-fans-of-mohammed-rafi-and-kishore-kumar.html#comment-5679 I request the web-master to post all messages posted by Kishore/Rafi fans. I sense some of messages posted by Rafi fans are not being approved. :( Ek dukhi ladki aur Kishore ki fan. :( Binu ji - I will disagree with you here. Read some of the comments written by diehard Rafi fans. I think it is in bad taste.

Actually there are such fans for both the artistes and it is not fair to say that some writers in this forum are writing anti-Rafi sahab. I love the songs of both these artistes though I am more of a Kishore fan as it is my own liking and passion.

Read this post - I think it is in real bad taste.

http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/an-endless-feud-between-the-fans-of-mohammed-rafi-and-kishore-kumar.html#comment-5679

I request the web-master to post all messages posted by Kishore/Rafi fans. I sense some of messages posted by Rafi fans are not being approved. :(

Ek dukhi ladki aur Kishore ki fan. :(

]]> by: binu nair http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5645 Thu, 13 Dec 2007 06:02:51 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5645 Anil ji : Most of Rafi saab fans and lovers love the songs of Kishore da too. They do not behave like fanatics or sectarians which is not the case with some writers in this forum...... binu nair Anil ji :

Most of Rafi saab fans and lovers love the songs of Kishore da
too.

They do not behave like fanatics or sectarians which is not the
case with some writers in this forum……

binu nair

]]> by: Anil http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5591 Fri, 07 Dec 2007 22:23:15 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5591 Dipankar, Come down to earth! Many of the classical singers can sing great songs which can only be understood by people like you! If you don't like kishore-da then you really don't deserve to be a Rafi fan. By the way what is taans, alaaps? Music has no language! Just feel it! If you can feel it then that is YOUR feeling! Dipankar,

Come down to earth! Many of the classical singers can sing great songs which can only be understood by people like you! If you don’t like kishore-da then you really don’t deserve to be a Rafi fan.

By the way what is taans, alaaps? Music has no language! Just feel it! If you can feel it then that is YOUR feeling!

]]> by: Dipankar http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5577 Thu, 06 Dec 2007 14:58:01 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5577 LMAO!!! This is the problem of us asians. We dont want to accept what the truth is , our views are biased. Kishore kumar didn't have harkats and taans in his voice which rafi had. But kishore had an awesome voice , very melodic. Guys , honestly ; rafi was a muslim but he sang man tarpat hari darshan ko aaj , an indian bhajan like a pandit. He sand semi classical songs like madhuban mein radhika nache re (where the classical part is very hard to attempt) . Rafi sang high songs , he sang sad songs , he sang inatoxicated songs , he sang happy songs , he sang cocky songs , he sang funny songs , he sang shabds (sikhs) , he sang bhajans (like pandits) , he sang muslim hamds and naats , he sang ghazals , he sang 2 english songs , he sang semi classical songs.!!!!!!! Is there ever been a singer like rafi then??? If you understand music , u must know that rafi was a master of harkats. And also his taans and alaaps are undisputed. Please acknowledge the truth , dont fool yourselves . Both singers are from india but try to understand which one was better. RAFI has got no match till date. EVEN sonu nigam the best singer in india right now and the only one that can cut a semi classical album loves RAFI. CZ he understands music. LMAO!!! This is the problem of us asians. We dont want to accept what the truth is , our views are biased. Kishore kumar didn’t have harkats and taans in his voice which rafi had. But kishore had an awesome voice , very melodic. Guys , honestly ; rafi was a muslim but he sang man tarpat hari darshan ko aaj , an indian bhajan like a pandit. He sand semi classical songs like madhuban mein radhika nache re (where the classical part is very hard to attempt) . Rafi sang high songs , he sang sad songs , he sang inatoxicated songs , he sang happy songs , he sang cocky songs , he sang funny songs , he sang shabds (sikhs) , he sang bhajans (like pandits) , he sang muslim hamds and naats , he sang ghazals , he sang 2 english songs , he sang semi classical songs.!!!!!!! Is there ever been a singer like rafi then??? If you understand music , u must know that rafi was a master of harkats. And also his taans and alaaps are undisputed.
Please acknowledge the truth , dont fool yourselves . Both singers are from india but try to understand which one was better. RAFI has got no match till date. EVEN sonu nigam the best singer in india right now and the only one that can cut a semi classical album loves RAFI. CZ he understands music.

]]> by: Hussain http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5234 Sun, 28 Oct 2007 21:45:57 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-5234 People keep saying that KK was never a trained singer, well why not. You mean to tell me he just got up every morning and started singing. Maybe he was never formally trained as a youngster but did train when he started singing. No one will has yet to have range in voice that Mohd. Rafi sahib had. He could sing anything from a ghazal to qawali to raag to a song in any mood. I love KK as much, but they were both different. I miss them both, and wish they were still alive. People keep saying that KK was never a trained singer, well why not. You mean to tell me he just got up every morning and started singing. Maybe he was never formally trained as a youngster but did train when he started singing. No one will has yet to have range in voice that Mohd. Rafi sahib had. He could sing anything from a ghazal to qawali to raag to a song in any mood. I love KK as much, but they were both different. I miss them both, and wish they were still alive.

]]> by: BOND007 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-4626 Sat, 18 Aug 2007 10:20:20 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-4626 Guys I challenge any songs of Kishore VS Rafi/Lata, anytime Kishore is any time best. Its very difficult to change people who does not understand music, singing + pure sheer of listening to a male voice + versitality what Kishore cannot put in words, he was exteremly talented. To be honest many and many feel Rafi's songs were all of similar style, may be those days composers had same kind of creating songs or the trend was that. Rafi could have done differently if had sung in a different generation but tell me about the VOICE what kishore had... extremly good. Pure Man's voice. Kishore sung best songs because he had the talent and support of people. Rafi was washed away there was no one to listen Rafi's songs once Kishore came to his peak. Time is the best example to say Kishore swept all good songs as people/directors/producers/music directors wished him to sing. Easily 70s and 80s belonged to Kishore, there was no way to look back till he expired. Take any of kishore's songs, I am sure none of previous singers or current or future singers can sing with such versitality with such good voice. I and my friends always feel God has made some people where their brains cannot be tuned at all, they stick to it even if its wrong, they cannot think beyond what they understand, just like the supporters of Rafi. They want to stay in 60s and cannot understand music because their brain is tuned to certain level and cannot go further :-) NO ARGUEMENT PLEASE ..... KISHORE IS BEST !!!! Guys I challenge any songs of Kishore VS Rafi/Lata, anytime Kishore is any time best. Its very difficult to change people who does not understand music, singing + pure sheer of listening to a male voice + versitality what Kishore cannot put in words, he was exteremly talented.

To be honest many and many feel Rafi’s songs were all of similar style, may be those days composers had same kind of creating songs or the trend was that. Rafi could have done differently if had sung in a different generation but tell me about the VOICE what kishore had… extremly good.
Pure Man’s voice.

Kishore sung best songs because he had the talent and support of people.
Rafi was washed away there was no one to listen Rafi’s songs once Kishore came to his peak.

Time is the best example to say Kishore swept all good songs as people/directors/producers/music directors wished him to sing. Easily 70s and 80s belonged to Kishore, there was no way to look back till he expired.

Take any of kishore’s songs, I am sure none of previous singers or current or future singers can sing with such versitality with such good voice.

I and my friends always feel God has made some people where their brains cannot be tuned at all, they stick to it even if its wrong, they cannot think beyond what they understand, just like the supporters of Rafi. They want to stay in 60s and cannot understand music because their brain is tuned to certain level and cannot go further :-)

NO ARGUEMENT PLEASE ….. KISHORE IS BEST !!!!

]]> by: Abhisek http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-4429 Sat, 28 Jul 2007 17:19:42 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-4429 Kishoreda is the greatest artist in the universe. Kishoreda is the greatest artist in the universe.

]]> by: Bolokrisna Bosu http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-4426 Sat, 28 Jul 2007 10:17:26 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-4426 There need be no debate about Kishor's talents and often-remarkable performance, and he of course shone well particularly well under Sr Burman's baton. Especially his several songs based on Khamaj - for example, Koi humdum na rahaa; musaafir hoong yaaro, to fix clear what I mean) were great, since, as one has written on this site (not this page), he did enjoy a certain inexplicable natural melodic flair which showed in certain types of songs mostly classical or semi-classical, or else straight notes using the Ragas in a non-classical manner. I want to only add a negative facet of his music, just so that we maintain an unbiassed and fair view of him. It is that towards the latter phase of his cine musica career, his voice became very very hoarse, either due to overexploitation with too many singing contracts, or due to songs mismatched to his innate singing qualities. There need be no debate about Kishor’s talents and often-remarkable performance, and he of course shone well particularly well under Sr Burman’s baton. Especially his several songs based on Khamaj - for example, Koi humdum na rahaa; musaafir hoong yaaro, to fix clear what I mean) were great, since, as one has written on this site (not this page), he did enjoy a certain inexplicable natural melodic flair which showed in certain types of songs mostly classical or semi-classical, or else straight notes using the Ragas in a non-classical manner. I want to only add a negative facet of his music, just so that we maintain an unbiassed and fair view of him. It is that towards the latter phase of his cine musica career, his voice became very very hoarse, either due to overexploitation with too many singing contracts, or due to songs mismatched to his innate singing qualities.

]]> by: Debjyoti http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-4416 Fri, 27 Jul 2007 06:13:09 +0000 http://www.yoodleeyoo.com/kishore-diary/kishore-s-d-burman-a-relationship-that-began-with-aradhana.html#comment-4416 Mr A Singh,I certainly know that koi humdum was based on jhinjhiti raaga. Mr A Singh,I certainly know that koi humdum was based on jhinjhiti raaga.

]]>